AFL #1 Overall Picks History
| Year | Team | Player |
| 2007 | Florida Sharks | LB D.J. Williams |
| 2008 | Seattle Seahawks | LB Jonathan Vilma |
| 2009 | Richmond Rebels | HB Carnell Williams |
| 2010 | Nebraska Natives | LB Shawne Merriman |
| 2011 | Richmond Ravens | S Troy Polamalu |
| 2012 | Richmond Ravens | DE Cory Redding |
| 2013 | Indianapolis Colts | DE Julius Peppers |
| 2014 | Denver Broncos | HB Reggie Bush |
| 2015 | Oakland Raiders | DE Mario Williams |
| 2016 | Michigan Wolverines | T Joe Thomas |
| 2017 | Davis Mustangs | HB Otis Tisdale |
| 2018 | New Jersey Knights | T Jake Long |
| 2019 | Carolina Cardinals | CB Deion Sanders |
| 2020 | Zuni Thunderbirds | CB Darin Dent |
| 2021 | Denver Broncos | T Jason Smith |
| 2022 | Vancouver Voles | T Mark VanderPoel |
| 2023 | ?? | ?? |
| 2024 | ?? | ?? |
| 2025 | ?? | ?? |